Midlife Dating: Laurie Gerber
The dating lies people tell after 50 are rarely about grand deception; most come from fear, and knowing what each one is hiding can save you months of wasted time and heartache.
Why People Lie in Dating Over 50
If you’ve spent any time in the dating pool, especially now, you already know this: people lie.
Not always in big, dramatic, scam-artist ways. Not always on purpose. But in small, strategic, sometimes completely unconscious ways that chip away at your chances of finding a genuinely good match.
As a dating coach for over 20 years, I’ve seen it all: on profiles, on first dates, and deep into what people hoped would become real, lasting relationships.
Most of these lies aren’t deliberate deception. Most of them come from fear. Fear of not being chosen. Fear of ending up alone. Fear of rejection. Fear that who they actually are won’t be enough to attract the right person.
According to Psychology Today, fear of rejection and the desire for social acceptance are among the most powerful drivers of dishonesty. In dating, that instinct goes into overdrive.
Here are the most common things people lie about in dating over 50, and what to do about each one.
The 7 Biggest Dating Lies People Tell After 50
Lie #1: Their Real Age
Let’s start with the obvious. Age misrepresentation is rampant.
Why? Because people are gaming the search filters on dating sites. They want to appear in results for younger partners. Or they genuinely feel like their number doesn’t reflect their energy or outlook on life.
“I feel 55, so I’ll just put 55.”
Here’s the problem: if someone lies about their age to get through the door, they’re starting the connection with a small deception that immediately chips away at mutual respect. And respect is not optional if you want real love.
Coaching: A small age lie is not automatically a dealbreaker. But it is a legit red flag. It tells you how that person handles insecurity, and how much autonomy they’re willing to give you when it comes to deciding what you want.
Lie #2: How They Actually Look
Old photos. Filtered photos. Strategic angles. You’ve seen it. And honestly? Maybe you’ve dabbled in it yourself.
The justification is always the same: “I just need to get the first date. My personality will do the rest.”
But dating shouldn’t be a bait-and-switch operation. When someone arrives looking noticeably different from their profile, it creates an immediate disconnect. The goal isn’t to impress everyone. The goal is to attract the right person. And if they’re your person, they’re going to find out what you actually look like.
Coaching: Post recent photos. Be accurate about your current appearance. You’re not casting a wide net. You’re fishing for one very specific person.
Lie #3: Health Issues
This one gets complicated. People don’t always volunteer information about being a cancer survivor, living with a chronic illness, managing a mental health challenge, or dealing with physical limitations.
I get it. These are deeply personal realities.
But when health directly affects your ability to show up in a relationship, emotionally, physically, or logistically, it becomes your partner’s business too. Especially now, when both of you are thinking hard about what a real partnership looks like day to day.
Coaching: You don’t have to disclose everything on date one. But if it affects the relationship, it needs to come out by date three, at the latest.
This is exactly the kind of conversation I dig into on my podcast. The concept of “liability compatibility,” understanding how to share the harder truths about yourself in a way that builds trust rather than panic, is one of the most important skills you can develop in dating after 50.
Lie #4: Sex — Interest, Ability, and Expectations
This one is big, and people rarely tackle it directly.
People misrepresent how much they want sex, how often, what they’re capable of, and what they’re genuinely open to. Why? Because they’re trying to mirror what they think the other person wants to hear.
Some men downplay their timeline to seem respectful. Some women minimize their desire to appear more appropriate, or claim to be open to things they absolutely are not. And plenty of people dodge the topic entirely, hoping chemistry will figure itself out.
I doubt it.
Sex is what separates a romantic partnership from a close friendship. Getting clear on it matters.
Coaching: If you can’t talk honestly about sex, you’re not ready to have it.
Lie #5: Money and Financial Reality
People inflate: income, lifestyle, and financial stability. All of it gets polished up for presentation.
The motivation makes sense: they want to appear like a solid match. But financial dishonesty is a landmine. Money affects everything: travel plans, living arrangements, retirement timelines, and the daily stress of just getting through the week. When the real picture comes out, it almost never goes smoothly.
Coaching: You don’t need to lead with your bank statements. But if your actual financial situation doesn’t match the version you’ve been presenting? Know that the gap will catch up with you.
Lie #6: Entanglements and Prior Obligations
People don’t always offer the full picture about an ex who’s still very much in the mix, adult children who need significant support, aging parents requiring ongoing care, or major legal and financial obligations.
These situations are completely normal at this stage of life. They are not disqualifying.
But when they’re hidden or played down, they set up confusion and unmet expectations. You think you’re dating someone available. In reality, they’re stretched thin across a dozen competing demands.
Coaching: You’re not looking for someone with zero responsibilities. You’re looking for someone who is honest about themselves and has real space for a partner.
Learning how to set dating expectations after 50 from the very first interaction is one of the most effective ways to flush out these hidden entanglements before you get attached.
Dating Lies People Tell After 50: The Most Damaging One of All
Lie #7: What They’re Actually Looking For
People say they want a serious relationship, real commitment, a true partner. What they actually want is company, something casual, or a temporary distraction from loneliness. They don’t say that because they think honesty will limit their options.
So they show up presenting themselves as relationship-ready when they’re not.
This is where people get hurt. Especially women who are dating with real intention and clear goals.
Coaching: Stop listening only to what someone says. Watch what they do. Consistency, follow-through, and emotional availability will always tell you more than words ever will.
So What Do You Do With All This?
You don’t go cynical.
You date with awareness.
There are genuinely good people out there who want real love and are capable of building something healthy. They are not gaming the system. They are showing up as themselves.
Your job, and it’s a straightforward one even if it’s not always easy, is this: notice inconsistencies, ask better questions, trust your own observations, and move on when something doesn’t add up.
The right person doesn’t ask you to look away from the truth.
Did you enjoy this article? Become a Kuel Life Member today to support our Community. Sign-up for our Sunday newsletter and get your content delivered straight to your inbox.
About the Author:
Laurie Gerber has been a dating coach for the last 20 years. She is the creator of Master the Art of Love, an online digital course for women over 50. ” She’s the host of the podcast “Love at Any Age,” and has been featured widely in print, on TV, radio, podcasts, and served as the resident love expert at Match, Zoosk, Jdate, etc. Her dating advice and free training can be found at lauriegerber.com.
